Sting parted with the Police in 1984 after the band’s fifth and most successful album, “Synchronicity.” There are a lot of cases where the color of the record label or the color of the vinyl can make a difference in value. But here’s a case where the color of the cover establishes value. Yellow, red, and blue covers are up to $10.00. Gold, gray, and brown are up to $50.00 while the same album with a black and white cover can sell for $100.00 today.