Paul Anka was one of the biggest teen idols of the 50’s & 60’s with huge hits such as “Diana,” “Puppy Love,” and “Put Your Head On My Shoulder,” which today is worth up to $50.00 with its picture sleeve. However, his most valuable record is one that most people have never heard of. In 1966 RCA Records released the Paul Anka single, “I Can’t Help Loving You.” It’s worth up to $250.00 today.